Are e-cigs Evil ? - Channel 5 phone in show !

[Deleted]

The article is due at 10:55 - the title still has "evil" in it whatever the FB page says

[kirrielad]

It's on at 10.55 people and looks promising!

[Jen]

Ah, good, the segment is on at 10:55, which means I don't have to sit through the rest of this sensationalist drivel!

[MarkS]

The preamble by the girl on the phones was very positive, but if you search "Anne Diamond Smoking" you might have an idea where this could go.

I hope I am wrong and that she also see's vaping as a positive, but I feel a torrent of conjecture being spouted from her corner.

God I'm so cynical at times....really hope I am wrong on this.

[Roscopecotrain]

I am working but will keep an eye on this thread as day goes on. I hope it goes well.

Sent from my Galaxy Note 2

[womble]

Mar 19, 2013 9:40:41 GMT MarkS said:

The preamble by the girl on the phones was very positive, but if you search "Anne Diamond Smoking" you might have an idea where this could go.

I hope I am wrong and that she also see's vaping as a positive, but I feel a torrent of conjecture being spouted from her corner.

God I'm so cynical at times....really hope I am wrong on this.

I just turned on the tv and saw it was Anne Diamond, my heart sank a little. I can't see her being positive.

[Deleted]

Kirsty has used them to kick the cigs & had nothing but positives to say about them, so there's at least one person in the studio that knows what they're talking about. Here's hoping that she's allowed to be involved in the actual discussion to get that across. It will be interesting....

[genguskhan]

Feel sorry for what happened to Anne Diamond but there is no way that this is going to go well when she says that if you smoke near a child you are a child abuser! But you never know?

[genguskhan]

Feel sorry for what happened to Anne Diamond but there is no way that this is going to go well when she says that if you smoke near a child you are a child abuser! But you never know?

[Deleted]

Don't have a tv so like not watching it as don't have a license (and tv licensing are giving me a hard enough time as is)...

Keep me informed....I will email the pcc if you tell me too

Bow down to the vape icon_shoppingm

[MarkS]

I doff my cap tom Mrs Diamond. The most balanced and informed opinion on the panel. Wow!

[MarkS]

Overall probably the most balanced piece on mainstream TV yet.

Although Matthew Wright did spew the old "unregulated" clap trap.

[kirrielad]

Well was short but sweet, not to bad on the whole imo

[Davy Tee]

Well done Lee from Wiltshire for ringing in even though the panel didnt really listen to what you were saying never mind. Wrighty just wanted him to admit he was still addicted to nicotine

[Deleted]

There, Anne actually stated a plus! Kirsty, well wasn't terribly helpful in the end, her piece earlier was better. Well done to Lee the caller though. We'll never be happy with the coverage, let's face it.