kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 27, 2014 19:21:02 GMT
I would! After that is, not before.
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 27, 2014 19:16:24 GMT
My comment to them.
As others have said the TPD will do nothing but bring down one of the best safer alternatives to smoking down to the same level as NRT, in other words a failure. While people were so busy bashing smoking and anything that looks like it they managed to kill the one chance that long term smokers have to stay off smoking long term. Good job! Just look at Snus as an example of ridiculous legislation that kills far more than it saves. Snus was banned a long time ago and lots have died from smoking related illnesses in that time that Snus may have had the chance to save, now it's Ecigs. The EU doesn't learn/ care, nor does public health, NGOs like yourselves and tobacco control. All complicit in causing many 1000s of needless deaths. Anything that reduces the effectiveness of ecigs reduces the benefits to smokers. I also agree that as ecigs don't cause cancer they aren't your concern.
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
forums
Feb 27, 2014 19:04:00 GMT
Post by kibbster on Feb 27, 2014 19:04:00 GMT
VTTV yes because it uses ecig sponsorship which will be illegal, but there are workarounds so I doubt very much VTTV will go anywhere Forums probably not as long as there isn't ecig advertising. Unless the fact the forums are sponsored and we are talking about ecigs counts as one and the same... not sure.
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 27, 2014 8:38:25 GMT
Just realised the last sentence made no sense lol The perils of trying to respond to a blog whilst feeding a baby on the other arm I guess So write some comments but try to make more sense then I did hehe
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 27, 2014 8:34:06 GMT
www.rebeccataylor.eu/2014/02/26/good-news-for-tobacco-control-less-so-for-e-cigarettes/Rebecca has left a blog on the TPD results. She did speak to us (more than most MEPs did) she listened to us but she was still adamant that the TPD is a good thing and arbitrary restriction on E-cigs aren't a bad thing. She still bought into the Daily Fail hype. Although in her defence she stuck to here guns... kind of.. and didn't vote for Article 18a yesterday... unlike her colleague who shall not be mentioned. Anyway, feel free to leave a comment, I did. "Whilst I do appreciate the work you did for vapers leading up to the ridiculous Article 18a (which shouldn't even have been in a tobacco directive.) The future is still anything but rosy for vapers and there is no doubt that it will drive a percentage of vapers back to smoking. The regulations are over the top and inflict arbitrary and needless restrictions on a technology that has been quoted as the end game for smoked tobacco and the biggest public health prize since vaccines! And all we’ve heard from most MEPs is that the restrictions are for the mythical health of some imaginary children that don’t yet exist according to all available data. I’ve never heard of any consumer product before that is getting draconian laws when there is no known evidence of harm and in fact quite the opposite. The basic point I’m trying to make is that any over-restriction on e-cigs lowers them close to their main rival, the deadly (if you believe the science) tobacco cigarette. If you want to make a dent in tobacco sales do you try and restrict the deadly tobacco or do you restrict the safer alternative and the one technology around that given the time it needs to innovate could end smoked tobacco use? Forgive me if I can’t understand why nibbling at the edges of the least popular tobacco products (Menthol many years away, novelty cases that no one has ever seen, flavourings that no one has ever smoked and graphic warnings that are a badge of honour rather than a deterrent) As for banning sales of the most deadly consumer product known to man in smaller quantities… excuse me!? Am I right in thinking that you want people to smoke less so you’ll only allow them to buy cigarettes in larger quantities? Really!? That makes sense does it? I guess if that makes sense then I could see how restricting the 99.9% safer alternative also makes sense… In an mirror universe. So anyway, I believe your heart and ambitious really are in the right place and at least you abstained rather than actively try to destroy vapers from within like your colleague did by voting for both Article 18a and the TPD! The fact you could have voted for the TPD (for all the good it’ll do anyone) and still have voted against the draconian EU laws on ecigs is neither here nor there. Please don’t keep saying “It could have been worse” as if that’s a positive vapers should be rejoicing in the streets. I know you were up against tough times in the TPD defending ecigs, you are one of the few who actually engaged with us, but for me what you do speak much louder than what you say. "
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 27, 2014 7:45:28 GMT
To add:
Once this does become UK law, the UK vapers/ trade bodies can take the UK government to court and get it overthrown. But until something is implemented there's nothing to take to court.
On time scales, no one really knows. The maximum time frame is mid-late 2016, but the work will have to start on the UK version of the TPD long before that. Knowing how desperate the UK government is to retain it's £12 billion tobacco revenue a year, expect it to be sooner rather than later.
You can also bet your arse that Big pharma is already lobbying the UK Gov on your behalf. I wouldn't really let them speak for you on E-cigs, if you don't let your MP know what you want then my guess is they'll go with the Pharma view on ecigs.
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 27, 2014 7:40:39 GMT
Ok so it's the day after the morning before and I've been doing some more reading up on this.
Panic aside, it still has to be ratified by all member states (apparently though that's certain to go through.) Then the member states have to write their own laws with the EU TPD limit as the maximum (I suspect most will use the TPD as guidance and just write the TPD into national law.)
We have to write to our MPs who will soon be involved in that process, the process will have to be debated and could take quite a while but start dialogue early with your MP gives you more time to turn them around if they are anti. Also visit your MP and show them you are a human being and the devices you use.
Finally vape openly and vape proud, this is now a hearts and minds battle on our home turf, we need as many people on side as possible including the general public because public opinion will sway the tone of the new law in the UK. All the MPs want to keep their jobs remember.
The battle isn't over and in a way it's got easier because our MPs are directly responsible to us, unlike MEPs and our votes count!
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 26, 2014 23:09:00 GMT
Article 18 is not realy detailed enough to know what the implications will be. For the detail we will get that from uk legislation, which could go either way. It would be possible for parliament to take a light handed approach within The directive, which wouldn't be too bad (or loose enough for us to dodge round) On the other hand any of the elements Could be taken to extremes that would outlaw everything. They can even go with med regs only, which would also sink us. We need to all pester our MPs and keep them from taking the harshest view. That is very true. The next battle is in the UK, MPs are listening to us (unless they are Labour) and we've got further in the last 6 months than anyone could have imagined. Six months ago we were sunk and we are still here and vaping, for now. We need to write to our MPs on masse and get them to back us when the UK gets to make it's decisions on how it implements it's interpretation of the TPD. It won't be better than the TPD for us, but it's down to us stop the UK making it worse than the TPD.
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 26, 2014 22:53:02 GMT
Evods are in? Protanks are out. If I have multiple Protanks, can I buy evod coils? Now, where's my nic base? (better get some more RBAs) Luckily they use the same coils
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 26, 2014 22:30:52 GMT
I think you'll find you will only be able to purchase 10ml bottles of 18mg juice. Thanks toots, I have read so many websites most of which I do not understand since getting home this evening that I am now totally confused. Is this what has been passed today? Does this mean that we are safe to say between now and 2016 no change, after 2016 these are the only changes? ( until they hold a new meeting ) To save me more grief, as my pc is now not loading the page correctly, ( internet up and down ) would you mind listing what is now unable to be purchased - looking at in from a general vapers point of view. No 2016 is the latest member states can bring in the new law, it has to be in place by then. I suspect the EU is more than fine with it being brought in early if member states choose to do so.
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 26, 2014 22:29:19 GMT
kibbster ?? So I can buy an evod , the coils, an mvp, and a 30ml bottle of 18mg from any vendor I choose? This is forever?? Or until next meeting??? You won't be able to buy a 30ml bottle, anything over 10ml is banned. Obviously nothing to stop you buying 3x10ml and decanting it yourself into a bigger bottle, but price might increase based on 10ml being more expensive than larger quantities and the fact that vendors will need a medicines license to order more than 20mg base. If they are mixing 18mg from 20mg base you aren't going to get good value for money with premixed or DIY. This is forever or until we can get it over turned in court, it's now EU law. Only good thing is this isn't instant, member states have until 2016 to implement the law. That doesn't mean it won't happen till 2016, but that's the latest it can happen.
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 26, 2014 22:23:19 GMT
Ok managed to get this to load up - of all the days for my internet to go on a go slow stop - It says - Cartridge size will be capped at 2ml. E-cigarettes will be limited to a maximum permitted nicotine concentration level of 20mg/ml So they can't take away clearo's that we own, so 2ml is not a problem. The next bit - E-cigarettes will be limited to a maximum permitted nicotine concentration level of 20mg/ml, is that talking about cartridges - as in cig a likes? What about pre- made eliquid? All characterising flavours will be banned - what flavours are characterising, and which are not? You forget something about clearos - a lot of them are over 2ml. Aspire BDC Novas, Protanks, Nautilus, unitank etc all illegal. Lots of RBAs over 2ml and I guess they are illegal as well. Evods and iclear16s, CE*. about all we'll get. And considering 1clears and Evods aren't leakproof when refilling, we won't get those either. We'll be waiting for a while for replacements with the six month application for all new devices with testing and contact information. I believe in two years, they'll be reviewing if they want to ban all refillables (not sure if that's still in Art18.) The UK has already said the only permissible flavours will be the ones allowed in NRT and I haven't seen them change their tune on that so I would guess menthol, a random fruit flavour and possibly a blackcurrent sort of flavour. No one is entire sure yet, let alone the EU themselves, but what ever they have in store for us it's not going to be pretty so we will have to fight to avoid disposable cartridge look-alikes which is all the EU really want. Actually, if I think rightly even auto batteries are banned because all ecigs have to be childproof. Vendors can sell existing stock but once the hammer comes down, vaping as we know it is changed for the worse till we can sort this mess out. Art18 is a complete clusterfuck, not least because it's open to member states interpretation. They can't allow more than the TPD decrees but they are more than welcome to allow as much less as they want. If the UK wants a limit of 1ml @ 2mg they can. What a mess
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 26, 2014 20:06:16 GMT
As long as the clearo is smaller than 2ml and the liquid is less than 20mg... yes.
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 26, 2014 17:55:35 GMT
Sky's traffic shaping was a dreadful nightmare! Moved to BT now where they don't limit speeds, all good so far.
|
|
kibbster
Super Member
May your atty always run wet
Joined:November 2012
Posts: 2,819
Location:
Likes: 1,570
Recent Posts
Last Online Jul 17, 2015 5:45:00 GMT
|
Post by kibbster on Feb 26, 2014 10:52:38 GMT
I had a reply this morning. Utterly useless as expected (my MEPs are pretty much all UKIP)
Still, I exercised my democratic right.
|
|